Is the Universe Too Big for its Age?


If the Universe is 13.8 billion years old and cosmic speed limit is 386,000 mi/s, how can the radius of the universe be 46.5 billion light-years?

Modern instruments see light that is 13.8 billion years old. Due to the expansion of the universe, its waves have been stretched into microwaves, the cosmic microwave background (CMB). But, while that light traveled 13.8 billion years to get here, the universe was busy accelerating outward in all directions, taking that object with it, up to 46.5 light-years away.

For example, telescopes see GN-z11 (picture below) as it was 13.39 billion years ago. Meanwhile, that galaxy was swept many more billions of light-years away by of the expanding universe. Light from the oldest objects has already been stretched never reach Earth. There is no limit on how fast the universe can expand, only on how fast things inside the universe can move relative to each other.

It’s somewhat like the case of two inchworms crawling in opposite directions on a 10-inch elastic band at one inch per minute. If the band is stretched to twice its length during the first minute, the inchworms will be four inches apart rather than the two inches predicted by their top speeds.

As the expansion continues, more and more distant objects cross the horizon of observability where not even light-speed travel would be fast ever catch up to it. 

So, we have an estimate from science of 93 billion light-years for the diameter of that part of the universe whose objects beam light that could reach Earth at some point in the future. Studies of the CMB suggest that the radius of universe is 250 times that.
We can’t rule out the possibility of an infinite universe. It’s possible that the observable portion of the Big Bang is but a small ripple in an infinite universe that is unknowable. 

That doesn’t mean that the universe would have been around for an infinite amount of time. Infinity is not a measurement. It’s a concept. Even if an infinite amount of time could produce an infinite universe, a doubtful assumption, an infinite amount of time has not yet passed. So, if the universe as a whole is infinite, it must be without beginning.